- Pace Business School1
- Passaic Valley High School (Little Falls, N.J.)1
- Peekskill High School (Peekskill, N.Y.)1
- Pequannock Township High School (Pequannock, N.Y.)1
- Piscataway Township High School (Piscataway, N.Y.)1
- Port Richmond High School (Staten Island, New York, N.Y.)4
- Port Washington High School (Port Washington, N.Y.)1
- Prospect Heights High School (Brooklyn, New York, N.Y.)1
- Queen of the Rosary1
- Ralph J. Osgood High School (Kings Park, N.Y.)1
- Regis High School (New York, N.Y.)1
- Rhodes School (New York, N.Y.)1
- Richmond Hill High School (New York, N.Y.)1
- Ridge Street School (Port Chester, N.Y.)1
- Riverdale Junior High School (Bronx, New York, N.Y.)1
- Roslyn High School (Roslyn Heights, N.Y.)1
- Rothschild Junior High School (Brooklyn, New York, N.Y.)1
- Russell Sage Junior High School (Forest Hills, New York, N.Y.)1
- Sacred Heart Academy (Hempstead, N.Y.)166
- Saint Aloysius High School (Jersey City, N.J.)15
- Saint Anthony High School (Jersey City, N.J.)11
- Saint Barnabas High School (Bronx, New York, N.Y.)1
- Saint Brendan High School (Brooklyn, New York, N.Y.)1
- Saint Brendan's Diocesan High School (Brooklyn, New York, N.Y.)3
- Saint Clare Academy (Hastings on Hudson, N.Y.)2
- Saint Dominic Academy (Jersey City, N.J.)169
- Saint Francis Xavier High School3
- Saint Helena High School (Bronx, New York, N.Y.)9
- Saint Joseph High School1
- Saint Joseph Hill Academy (Staten Island, New York, N.Y.)18
- Saint Joseph of the Palisades High School (West New York, N.J.)1
- Saint Joseph's High School11
- Saint Mary High School (Rutherford, N.J.)4
- Saint Mary's Villa Academy (Sloatsburg, N.Y.)1
- Saint Michael High School12
- Saint Peter's Preparatory School (Jersey City, N.J.)6
- Saint Raymond Academy (Bronx, New York, N.Y.)1
- Saint Saviour High School (Brooklyn, New York, N.Y.)1
- Saint Vincent Ferrer High School (Manhattan, New York, N.Y.)1
- Samuel J. Tilden High School (Brooklyn, New York, N.Y.)2
- Seton Hall Preparatory School (West Orange, N.J.)21
- Seward Park High School30
- Sheepshead Bay High School (Brooklyn, New York, N.Y.)3
- Shell Bank Junior High School (Brooklyn, New York, N.Y.)4
- St. Anthony High School (Jersey City, N.J.)8
- St. Cecilia High School (Englewood, N.J.)1
- St. Helena High School1
- St. Joseph's Girls' High School5
- St. Lukes High School (Hohokus, N.J.)1
- St. Michael Academy (Manhattan, New York, N.Y.)79
- St. Michael's High School (Jersey City, N.J.)1
- St. Patrick High School (Elizabeth, N.J.)1
- St. Peter's Preparatory High School (Jersey City, N.J.)2
- St. Simon Stock High School (Bronx, New York, N.Y.)1
- St. Stephen High School1
- Stella Maris High School (Queens, New York, N.Y.)9
- Teaneck High School (Teaneck, N.J.)2
- The Mary Louis Academy (Queens, New York, N.Y.)5
- Thomas A. Edison Career & Technical Education High School (Jamaica, New York, N.Y.)2
- Thomas Jefferson High School (Brooklyn, New York, N.Y.)2